Putting journalists at the centre of the media's democratic role

17 November 2026

The third edition of the European Agora for Journalism was held in Strasbourg between 4 and 6 November, 2026. The three-day event aimed "to rethink and defend journalism as a 'democratic shield' for Europe." Dr Eileen Culloty, FuJo's Deputy Director, was invited to contribute a reflection on journalism and AI in the context of media literacy. Her remarks, provided below, centred on the idea that:

Support for media literacy has increased significantly in recent years, in tandem with concerns about disinformation and now concerns about AI. One of the most notable developments is that media literacy is now mainstream. No longer confined to the classroom, media literacy is being integrated into the services of public libraries, public authorities and civil society organisations.

The rationale for this is grounded in a fundamental concern about the health of democracy: will citizens have access to reliable information and do they have the knowledge and skills to evaluate information? Most media literacy initiatives are grounded in those questions and as media literacy extends into AI literacy, it carries those questions forward. At its core, media literacy has little to say about journalists and the work they do because its primary focus is on the citizens' access to information and ability to evaluate it.

Policy and industry discussions about the impact of AI on the democratic role of journalism mirror those concerns by focusing on the provision of reliable information. In effect, discussions about media and democracy tend to prioritise the value of news outputs with very little to say about the value of news workers.

This is a big challenge for journalists who face a deeply uncertain future in the age of AI. In what follows, I will set out some parameters for a new narrative that prioritises journalistic work as core to democracy. Ultimately, however, the effort to change this narrative needs to come from journalists and their representative bodies.

AI and Journalism

There is no shortage of think-pieces about the implications of AI for trust in news and democracy. Many people and organisations are asking critical questions about what AI means for journalism.

The Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at Oxford University has a dedicated strand on AI and the Future of News, with reports on the use of AI chatbots to access information and the adoption of AI in newsrooms. The European Audiovisual Observatory recently held an event on the implications of AI for how people consume and trust information. The International Journalism Festival included a panel discussion on how to report on the tech industry and investigate the hype and realities surrounding AI.

These are all very important considerations. However, I think the starting point for any conversation about AI and journalism needs to be about the implications for journalistic work: specifically, what does AI mean for the kind of journalism that will (and won’t) be produced? And what does AI mean for the kind of workers that will (and won’t) be hired?

Conflated Interests: Newsrooms and Journalists

If work isn’t the focal point, journalists may find themselves in a trap that conflates the interests of media companies with the interests of media workers. In recent decades, this conflation has been normalised because the survival of the news industry entailed the survival of journalists.

As tech companies decimated the business model of journalism, news companies and journalists had a shared interest in finding any solution that would prevent newsrooms from closing. The arguments for offering public grants and subsidies to newsrooms were usually backed by academics and policymakers on the basis that good journalism is essential for democracy.

However, something else was happening to the news industry in the wake of digitalisation. Many outlets closed and many others were bought up. Now, the news industry is more concentrated than ever, with major conglomerates operating across borders and media sectors. As they navigate the AI era, the long-term interests of these companies do not necessarily overlap with the interests of journalists.

That is why we should be careful about how arguments about democratic value are constructed. Too often, those arguments define democratic value in terms of the final output: the investigation or court report. The role of the journalist as a professional with skills, experience and judgement may be implied, but is not explicitly identified as the source of democratic value.

News Deserts: An Illustrative Case

Concerns about news deserts offer a clear example of this distinction between valuing output over the professional. There are legitimate concerns about the closure of local and regional news outlets. Projects tracking regions at risk of becoming news deserts are valuable, as are efforts to mitigate closures. However, we should pay close attention to what is measured.

The temptation is to measure the output. The term “news desert” puts emphasis on news outputs. So news deserts are often measured in terms of the number of newspapers, radio stations and TV companies operating in a region, or the volume of reports they generate on areas of public interest like courts and local government.

But consider whether news outputs can exist without professional journalists, or with very few?

It’s not hard to imagine because it’s already happening. Newsrooms have already downsized. Many already centralise content across a portfolio of brands and use “content creators” rather than journalists to re-package stories for different audiences and platforms. Many “local” newspapers are filled with the same recycled content from across a network of outlets.

There are still some local journalists reporting on events, but it’s very easy to see how they could be replaced with AI. After all, AI is very good at generating output. It can easily summarise the content of meetings, extract data from online exchanges about events, and repackage stories for different audiences.

If a region has a local newspaper, but doesn’t have any local journalists, should it be considered a news desert? Bound up with that question is whether the news outlet deserves public subsidies if it is keeping a news title open but doesn’t have any local journalists.

Another question: what is lost when there is no professional journalist in a region? This question is another way of asking what is lost when we define the democratic value of journalism in terms of outputs rather than professional practice. If we don’t do a better job of explaining why journalists themselves matter for democracy, the profession risks being swept up in the AI efficiency drive.

Pushing Back Against AI

If journalists are to secure the future of their profession, they need to have a coherent position on AI and its integration into the workplace.

This won’t be easy. It is never easy to push back against a technological revolution, and AI is undoubtedly a technological revolution. But revolutions and their consequences are famously hard to predict and the future is not determined. The arguments we make now are vitally important for securing that future.

One difficulty is the narratives that surround AI. In particular, the narrative of inevitability: “AI is here”, “AI is the future”. Then there are those who embrace AI and those who reject it, and they are locked in arguments about progress.

To navigate these narratives, I think it’s helpful to make a distinction between AI research, AI tools, and AI as a new frontier for major tech companies. We should all be able to celebrate the achievements of AI research over the past 50–60 years. We can also recognise that there are many great applications for AI ; including tools that genuinely help journalistic work and investigations.

And then there are powerful AI companies - most of the concern about AI lies with this group. Therefore, you can embrace AI research and tools while being extremely critical of AI tech companies.

It is in the interests of these companies to push their tools into workplaces. They know how to do it because tech companies have done it before: locking public and private institutions into their commercial products. Indeed, in Europe it is good to see efforts finally to extract ourselves from these products.

But this drive to embed AI in everything has consequences. One of the most concerning is cognitive offloading, whereby AI undermines people’s ability to think and apply their own knowledge and skills. There is growing evidence for this, including evidence from the tech companies themselves. When workers become reliant on AI, there’s a risk of significant skills collapse. This appears to have a bigger impact on younger people because they do not have decades of experience of working without AI.

So what can journalists do? The first thing is to recognise that the issues journalists face are being faced by many other sectors. Securing the future of journalism work is tied to securing the future of human work more generally.

Learning from Luddites

Journalists can look to the past and another technological revolution. Two hundred years ago, the Industrial Revolution began in Britain. The skilled weavers who worked in the textile industry found themselves being replaced by machines. In response, they started to destroy the machines, and history remembers them unkindly as the “Luddites”.

The word “Luddite” is generally used as a synonym for technophobe, with a vague pop-cultural understanding that the original Luddites were short-sighted peasants who just wanted to put a stop to progress itself. This is not true. The Luddites were not technophobes at all. What they opposed was de-skilling and worsening conditions.

Gavin Mueller’s excellent book Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Were Right About Why You Hate Your Job explains this in detail, and makes a compelling argument about why Luddism should be part of any successful resistance to the tech industry’s latest assaults on workers’ autonomy.

I'm not suggesting journalists need to break their office machines, but they can consider what Luddism looks like for journalism. Should there be limits on what journalists will and won’t accept with AI use?

What would “pushback” actually look like for journalists and their representative bodies? For example, collective bargaining, refusal clauses, transparency requirements, subsidy conditions tied to journalistic work, public campaigning? What is the realistic target: slowing adoption, shaping terms, protecting skills, or something else? And who are the allies: other unions and sectors, policymakers, academics, audiences?

The answers to these questions are yet to be decided, but what should be clear to journalists is that they need to insert themselves more forcefully into arguments about media and democracy and they need to find ways to name and measure the democratic value of the work they do beyond the outputs they deliver.

Participants

Dr Eileen Culloty

Eileen Culloty is an Associate Professor in the School of Communications where she is Deputy Director of the DCU Institute for Media, Democracy, and Society and chair of the BA in Communication Studies. Her work focuses on disinformation, media literacy education, and the future of public media. Eileen leads the Ireland Hub of the European Digital Media Observatory (EDMO) and serves as Co-Chair of Media Literacy Ireland, the national network for media literacy coordinated by Coimisiún na Meá...

Related News

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience. The majority of the cookies used on this website are associated with analytics, collecting information about how visitors use our site. The cookies collect information in an anonymous form that does not identify an individual. Learn more
Current status: AcceptedDeclinedNot yet accepted